Commonly known as America's first seaside resort, Cape May’s Victorian charm, walkable beachside streets, and historic shorefront architecture make it one of the most travel-worthy towns on the Jersey Shore.
Whatever brings you to Cape May, whether it's a romantic getaway, family vacation, or a beach trip with friends, you'll want to find the place that perfectly captures the vibe you're after. Check our official guide on the best hotels and accommodations in Cape May, NJ, so you can find a place that suits your style—and make the most of your time in this historic town.
Is it Worth Visiting Cape May, NJ?
Cape May is the southernmost county in New Jersey, and technically part of the Jersey Shore, but it's decisively not the Jersey Shore you may have seen on reality TV. It's a much quieter seaside experience, and a National Historic Landmark due to its high concentration of Victorian buildings, with the "second-largest collection of Victorian houses, behind San Francisco", according to CapeMayCity.
Aside from its stunning Victorian architecture, Cape May is renowned for having some of the best beaches in the US, along with a quaint downtown district offering great shopping and dining options. It's a known destination for nature lovers, particularly those with a penchant for birds (it's a known bird-watching spot during migration seasons).
The 7 Best Hotels to Stay in Cape May, NJ
1. Congress Hall
$261-$1,196
stars
Known as America’s first seaside resort, Congress Hall has been welcoming guests for over 200 years, since its opening in 1816. The property exudes an antiquated charm but offers modern conveniences, perfectly situated on Cape May's famous beachfront. Located on Beach Avenue, Congress Hall earns a walkability score of 96 on TripAdvisor, making it extremely convenient and within a short walking distance of Washington Street Mall, as well as popular Cape May restaurants and attractions.
The hotel restaurant, The Blue Pig Tavern, serves breakfast, lunch, and dinner with a regionally inspired menu and ingredients (think local oysters or New England clam chowder). The hotel lounge and cocktail bar, The Brown Room, serves Prohibition-era cocktails and is a Cape May local haunt, featuring daily live music and small bites.
Famous hotel lounge and cocktail bar, The Brown Room, with live music
Guest Reviews
Guests who love Congress Hall say it has a great vibe, with live music performances daily. The beach service, including complimentary towels, umbrellas, and chairs, is appreciated by guests and makes packing lighter (without having to bring towels).
Reviews note the hotel's central location, but several comments mention the level of noise being a concern. Additionally, the hotel is busy during peak travel season, so securing a dinner spot or seats in the cocktail bar can be a challenge. It's recommended to make dinner reservations in advance.
2. ICONA Cape May
$219-$1,228
stars
ICONA Cape May is a modern beachfront hotel with whitewashed exteriors and coastal-modern interiors. It’s a stylish property, ideal for those who wish to have immediate beach access and value cleanliness and convenience.
Located on Beach Avenue, ICONA Cape is not a full-service hotel, as it does not have an on-site restaurant or bar. That said, specific rooms come with a small kitchenette, which includes a sink, a Keurig machine, a microwave, a fridge, and silverware, so you can save on eating out for each meal. The friendly staff and spotless rooms make it a reliable choice, especially for couples and families.
Guest Reviews
ICONA Cape guest reviews on TripAdvisor are overwhelmingly positive, with many commenting on the clean, coastal-modern accommodations and the prime beachfront location. The staff is reportedly helpful and responsive to guests' concerns and requests. While there's no on-site dining, it's a short and enjoyable walk to the nearby restaurants and shops. Booking dinner reservations in advance is recommended.
3. The Virginia Hotel & Cottages
$225-$1,019
stars
The Virginia Hotel & Cottages is an adults-only boutique hotel in an impeccably restored landmark building constructed in 1879. The hotel is known for providing guests with personalized service, cozy, modest suites, and is centrally situated near the main restaurants and shops.
Ensconced on Jackson Street, in the famous historic district of Cape May, The Virginia is a block from the beach and within walking distance to Washington Street Mall. Guests can book a room at the Virginia Hotel proper, or for a more private getaway, one of the Virginia Cottages. Amenities from sister properties, including a spa and pool, are available for all guests to enjoy.
The hotel restaurant, The Ebbitt Room, with farm-to-table fine dining
Guest Reviews
Guests rave about the quiet, upscale vibe of Virginia, noting its romantic ambiance and thoughtful touches, such as the hotel's turndown service. Guests love the complimentary breakfast and the option to use amenities at nearby sister properties. While the rooms are cozy and well-decorated, some suggest requesting a larger suite is better for longer stays.
4. The Southern Mansion
$469-$938
stars
A coveted wedding venue set on 1.5 acres of lush, manicured gardens, The Southern Mansion offers a more secluded stay in the heart of Cape May. Built in 1863 and restored with period antiques, this B&B-style hotel delivers grandeur and comfort—and it’s only a 10-minute walk to the beach, main shopping area, and is across the street from the renowned Washington Inn restaurant. The property features 24 rooms, serves a complimentary gourmet breakfast daily, and is said to be frequented by some other-worldly visitors (i.e., people claim it's haunted).
Guest Reviews
Guests describe The Southern Mansion as a peaceful setting, featuring immaculate, spacious rooms and historic décor that contrasts with modern amenities. Several reviews highlight the breakfast, saying it's a great value that will keep you full till dinner. Some feedback notes that some of the furnishings and amenities could use an update.
5. La Mer Beachfront Resort
$217-$864
stars
La Mer is a favorite for families and couples wanting ultimate comfort steps from the ocean. It's toward the quieter, north end of Beach Avenue. They recently renovated in November 2024, primarily updating the accommodations along Beach Avenue and adding a new swimming pool.
The hotel restaurant, The Pier House, serves upscale Mediterranean entrees, seafood, and, of course, offers cocktails and patio seating. You’ll find everything you need—a casual beachfront restaurant, pool, and even space for weddings or events—all while being just a short drive from Cape May Point State Park and other sites.
Guest Reviews
Guests frequently describe La Mer as a hidden gem in Cape May, appreciating its quieter setting. A guest review from July 2025 notes that the accommodations are "clean, upscale, and amazingly well-appointed". Families say it's a great place to bring kids, and that the beachfront setting is worth the cost.
6. The Sandpiper Beach Club
$216-$1,284
stars
Operated by the Cape Resorts group (i.e., Congress Hall and the Virginia), the Sandpiper is an all-suite property, known for being ultra-family-friendly. Accommodations here are especially well-suited for longer travel stays, larger groups, and families who require convenience.
The suites available include 1- and 2-bedroom options, living rooms with pull-out sofas, full kitchens, private balconies, laundry facilities, and, to top it off, you're right across from the beach. Amenities include beach access and cabanas with waiter service, a heated pool, a fitness room, and a sauna.
Guest Reviews
Guest reviews highlight the flexibility and convenience of cooking meals in the hotel kitchen, which comes fully stocked with dishes, glasses, coffee, pots, and pans. For those on a budget who want to save on dining out, this adds significant value.
The accommodations are larger than standard rooms, and the living areas with the pull-out couches are a bonus for anyone traveling in groups. Weekend rates can be pricey during peak season, but most say it's worth it.
7. Boarding House Cape May
$299-$678
stars
A newly renovated Cape May hotel, The Boarding House is a pet-friendly boutique hotel with easy access to both the downtown area and the beach. A surf-inspired haven, Boarding House Cape May pays homage to the sport with surfboards hanging on the walls as decor.
Though the property is not directly on the beachfront, it's a quick bike ride or walk to both the beach and downtown Cape May. With its laid-back, surf-inspired decor and thoughtful amenities like dog-washing stations (they're pet-friendly), this spot stands out for its low-key vibes and offers something different from the more traditional Cape May-style accommodations.
Guest Reviews
Travelers love the low-key, dog-friendly vibe at the Boarding House. The rooms are said to be clean, and the decor adds a fun, surf-inspired flair. Some guests mention it's a bit farther from the beach compared to others, but the quiet location and casual atmosphere more than make up for it.
FAQs
Absolutely—it’s one of the most pedestrian-friendly towns on the Jersey Shore, with many hotels within walking distance of the beach, restaurants, and Washington Street Mall.
You won't need a car if you stay near the center of town or beachfront, but having one helps if you want to check out Cape May Point State Park or explore more of the island.
Peak travel season is from June through August. For fewer crowds and lower accommodation rates, it's recommended to visit Cape from May to September, or early October.
There are numerous excellent hotels in Cape May that are ideal for families of all sizes. Sandpiper Beach Club and La Mer, to name a few, both have spacious suites, expansive pools, and easy beach access.
There is no shortage of pet-friendly accommodations in Cape May, NJ. In fact, according to BringFido (the world's leading pet travel resource), there are at least 71 hotels in Cape May that accommodate your furry friends. Always check confirmed availability and pet policies when booking.
